Fresh Tomato Sauce - $4.11 a serving

Makes 6 servings · italian · medium · USDA MyPlate Kitchen (public domain)
$24.63
basket total, in-store
$4.11
per serving (6 servings)
-$0.52
cheaper than the $4.62 median dinner

Every non-staple ingredient matched to a real product on the shelf, priced on 2026-07-19 at Kroger - Kroger On the Rhine (ZIP 45202). 2 pantry staples excluded. 2 matches are flagged for you to check rather than silently swapped. Prices change without notice - this is what we paid attention to on that date, not a quote.

The recipe saysWe foundPackageUsesCostsLeft over
1. 8 ripe tomatoesKroger Vine Ripe Tomatoes · 20 ozx2 est.$3.198$5.40$0.98
3. 1/2 cup onion, choppedJumbo Yellow Onions · 1 lb$1.1980 g$0.21$0.98
4. 1/2 cup green pepper, choppedFresh Large Green Bell Pepper · 1 ct$0.9975 g$0.00$0.99
5. 1/4 cup carrot, thinly sliced, or shreddedCarrots · 1 lb$1.6930 g$0.11$1.58
6. 2 teaspoons garlic, minced (or 1/2 teaspoon garlic powder)Kroger® Whole Garlic Bulbs · 5 ctSIZE UNREAD - 1 PKG ASSUMED$2.496 g$2.49-
7. 1/2 teaspoon dried oreganoCHECK THISSmart Way™ Oregano Leaves · 0.63 oz$1.251 g$0.07$1.18
8. 1 teaspoon dried basilCHECK THISKroger® Basil Leaves Shaker · 0.43 oz$1.991 g$0.16$1.83
10. 6 cups cooked pastaKroger® Penne Rigate Pasta · 16 ozx2$1.33840 g$2.46$0.20
11. 6 tablespoons Parmesan cheese, gratedPrivate Selection® Parmesan Wedge Cheese · 8 oz$5.9960 g$1.58$4.41

ripe tomatoes drives this basket at $6.38, 26% of the total. The next biggest lines are parmesan cheese ($5.99) and pasta ($2.66). $12.14 of the basket - 49% - is package remainder: food you buy because stores sell packages and recipes call for amounts. It does not vanish, it sits in your kitchen for the next meal.

Fresh vegetables are cooked with herbs to create a flavorful and savory sauce for pasta, and other dishes, too!

This recipe is credited to a partner program (Farm Fresh Summertime Recipes Connecticut Food Policy Council), so we don't reprint its directions - read them on the archived original.

Farm Fresh Summertime Recipes Connecticut Food Policy Council. MyPlate took its recipe pages offline in 2026 - the original lives on at the Internet Archive. More on this: What dinner actually costs in 2026.
Build my cheapest weekPrice this at my store