Butternut Squash & Apple Soup - $9.55 a serving

Makes 4 servings · american · medium · USDA MyPlate Kitchen (public domain)
$38.20
basket total, in-store
$9.55
per serving (4 servings)
+$4.93
dearer than the $4.62 median dinner

Every non-staple ingredient matched to a real product on the shelf, priced on 2026-07-19 at Kroger - Kroger On the Rhine (ZIP 45202). 3 pantry staples excluded. 2 matches are flagged for you to check rather than silently swapped. Prices change without notice - this is what we paid attention to on that date, not a quote.

The recipe saysWe foundPackageUsesCostsLeft over
1 medium onion (chopped)Jumbo Yellow Onions · 1 lb$1.191$0.29$0.90
1 medium celery stalk (chopped)CHECK THISSleeved Celery · 1 ct$2.591$2.59-
1 medium carrot (chopped)Carrots · 1 lb$1.691$0.22$1.47
2 tablespoons olive oil (or cooking oil of choice)Simple Truth Organic® Extra Virgin Olive Oil · 16.9 fl oz$8.4930 ml$0.51$7.98
1 medium butternut squash (peeled, seeded, and chopped)Butternut Squash · 1 lbSIZE UNREAD - 1 PKG ASSUMED$1.491$1.49-
1 medium tart apple (peeled, cored, and chopped)CHECK THISLarge Granny Smith Apple - Each · 1 lb$1.991$0.79$1.20
3 teaspoons low-sodium bouillon (1 tablespoon)Better Than Bouillon® Reduced Sodium Beef Base · 8 oz$5.9915 g$0.40$5.59
1/8 teaspoon cayenne pepperKroger® Ground Red Cayenne Pepper Shaker · 1.5 oz$4.99-$4.99-
1/8 teaspoon cinnamonMcCormick Ground Cinnamon · 2.37 oz$3.79-$3.79-
1/8 teaspoon nutmegPrivate Selection® Ground Nutmeg Shaker · 1.72 oz$5.99-$5.99-

olive oil drives this basket at $8.49, 22% of the total. The next biggest lines are low-sodium bouillon ($5.99) and nutmeg ($5.99). $17.14 of the basket - 45% - is package remainder: food you buy because stores sell packages and recipes call for amounts. It does not vanish, it sits in your kitchen for the next meal.

This recipe is credited to a partner program (Virginia Cooperative Extension - www.eatsmartmovemoreva.org), so we don't reprint its directions - read them on the archived original.

Virginia Cooperative Extension - www.eatsmartmovemoreva.org. MyPlate took its recipe pages offline in 2026 - the original lives on at the Internet Archive. More on this: What dinner actually costs in 2026.
Build my cheapest weekPrice this at my store